What the Data Says About Selling and Buying in Essex and Union County, NJ, Right Now

Written by

in

Homes in Maplewood and South Orange are selling for more this year than last, and by wider margins over asking. In Livingston, the numbers have moved the other way. For anyone selling or buying in Essex and Union County, New Jersey, this winter, those town-by-town differences matter more than any countywide average.

Mark Slade of Mark Slade Homes tracks these towns every week with his business partner, MaryCeu Nunes. Here is what their year-to-date numbers through late October show, compared with the same week in 2025.

Maplewood and South Orange Pulled Ahead of Last Year

Maplewood’s average sale price is about $1.27 million so far in 2026, up from about $1.03 million at this point last year, an increase of nearly 24 percent. Homes are selling for an average of 15.3 percent over asking, compared with 12.6 percent a year ago.

South Orange shows a similar pattern. The average sale price is about $1.21 million, up from about $1.06 million, and homes are selling at 14.7 percent over asking versus 11.2 percent last year.

Both towns also reached a new level at the top of the market. For the first time in Slade’s 17 years in real estate, each recorded a sale above $3 million. Maplewood’s sold for just over $3 million. In South Orange, a home listed at $3 million sold for $3.9 million. For sellers at the upper end, those sales are now part of the comparable data that buyers and appraisers will weigh in 2027.

Livingston Shows What Happens When Buyers Have More Choices

Livingston’s average sale price is higher this year, at about $1.40 million compared with about $1.32 million, but homes are selling at just 2.4 percent over asking, down from 4.6 percent at this point in 2025. That is a drop of nearly half.

Slade traces the change to inventory. With more homes on the market, buyers had more to choose from, and each property tended to draw fewer offers.

He compares representing a buyer to a quarterback reading the defense. Comparable sales show the landscape, but what matters most is how many offers the buyer is competing against. “The more offers, generally speaking, a property gets, the higher the price goes,” he says. When offers thin out, so do the premiums.

Rates and the Calendar Are Pulling in Opposite Directions

Slade’s 17 years of tracking show a consistent pattern: these towns perform better in the first half of the year than in the second. In 2025, Maplewood sat at 14.5 percent over asking at midyear and finished the year near 12.6 percent. By Slade’s math, homes that closed in the second half averaged closer to 10.5 percent over asking. This year, Maplewood peaked at 17.3 percent in the first half and has since eased to 15.3 percent.

That is why he sees mid-September through mid-November as historically the best stretch for buyers, and the quieter winter weeks that follow can offer similar room before the spring market picks up.

Interest rates complicate the picture. Freddie Mac’s weekly survey put the average 30-year fixed rate near 6 percent in February. It climbed to 7.40 percent in mid-October before easing to 7.24 percent as of October 29. At the October peak, the same monthly payment supported roughly 13 percent less mortgage than it did in February, and buyers with less buying power tend to write less aggressive offers.

Barring a major economic shock, Slade expects spring to bring competition back regardless of rates. He calls it the “bonus baby syndrome.” Buyers who work in or around Manhattan receive year-end bonuses and raises, then start shopping in the suburbs from January through May. “No matter what the interest rate is, you’re still going to see an avalanche of buyers,” he says.

That does not mean every buyer should rush. The team’s view is that the right time depends on a buyer’s finances and on finding a home that fits.

Union and Rahway Offer More House for the Money

For buyers who feel priced out of Maplewood or South Orange, Slade points to Union County. Essex County’s average property tax rate is among the highest in the region. It is in line with Westchester and western Long Island, which offer a similar 45-minute commute to Manhattan, but it is still higher as a share of home value than in Union County.

Prices are lower, too. The average sale price is about $598,000 in Union and about $543,000 in Rahway. By Slade’s estimate, a buyer could purchase about two and a half homes in Union, or close to three in Rahway, for the price of one average home in Montclair.

He encourages buyers to compare the full monthly cost, including property taxes, insurance and any association fees, since taxes can vary widely from one home to the next. More guidance is available on the team’s buyer resources page.

Early in the new year, the team will be watching new listings, buyer activity, interest rates, and how quickly well-priced homes draw offers. Slade will also track his hyper market index, the ratio of homes under contract to homes actively for sale in each town, which he uses as a current read on buyer demand relative to supply.

Mark Slade Homes is a Keller Williams team led by Mark Slade and MaryCeu Nunes, serving buyers and sellers in Maplewood, South Orange and communities across Essex, Union and Morris counties.

The team has closed One-Half Billion dollars in lifetime sales volume across 53 New Jersey municipalities and markets its listings through its trademarked SMART RE-SULTS Listing System.

Disclaimer: This article is based on information provided by the expert source cited above. It is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or real estate advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult qualified professionals before making any real estate or financial decisions.